Domain Reputation Checker: How to Assess Sending Health for Gmail and Outlook
Check public domain signals, authentication and provider reputation clues without relying on one misleading score.
By the BurnedInbox team · Published · 3 min read
A domain reputation checker should answer a useful question: What evidence suggests this domain is healthy or unhealthy for email sending, and what can I change? There is no public universal domain reputation number accepted by every inbox provider.
Run a first-pass scan: Check your domain's SPF, DKIM, DMARC, and public blocklists. Then inspect real messages and provider-specific data.
What you can check for free
| Signal | What it tells you | What it does not prove |
|---|---|---|
| SPF | Whether a DNS policy authorizes certain sending sources | That a given message passed SPF or aligned with From |
| DKIM | Whether a public key is published for a known selector | That the actual message was signed and validated |
| DMARC | Published policy and alignment expectations | That every sent message passed alignment |
| Public RBL listing | Whether one of the checked public lists contains a domain or IP | Whether Gmail and Outlook will inbox every message |
| MX | Where a domain's inbound mail is routed | The reputation of every outbound message |
| Sending-IP PTR | Reverse DNS configuration for a sending IP | The reputation of an entire ESP's network |
| Seed placement test | Where specific test messages were placed | Your true overall inbox rate for real recipients |
How to check Gmail reputation
If you control the sending domain and meet Google's eligibility/data requirements, register it in Google Postmaster Tools. Check available reputation, reported spam-rate, authentication and delivery-error information. Some views may be missing or delayed when there is insufficient traffic; absence of data is not proof that Gmail trusts a domain.
Google advises keeping the user-reported spam rate below 0.10% and avoiding 0.30% or above. These are not targets for open rate, reply rate or seed placement rate.
How to check Outlook and Microsoft-related issues
Microsoft uses its own signals and policies, which are not interchangeable with Gmail's. Check full NDR responses, recipient destination, and any applicable IP health information. For Outlook.com consumer destinations, Microsoft's high-volume authentication rules require SPF, DKIM and DMARC for senders at its specified threshold. Do not confuse Outlook.com consumer requirements with every Exchange Online B2B tenant configuration.
What to do with a bad result
SPF or DKIM missing: Confirm which systems actually send mail, correct DNS and test a real message.
DMARC fails: Check whether SPF or DKIM authenticates the same organizational domain as the visible From address. A valid DNS DMARC record alone cannot repair alignment.
Public blocklist hit: Identify the exact list, listed object, listed reason and its delisting process. Fix the sending problem before requesting removal.
Clean technical checks but poor placement: Compare the affected provider, campaign content, recipient quality, complaints, sending rate and historical trends. Do not keep editing DNS records that already pass.
Should you replace the domain?
A reputation problem does not always require buying new domains. Use the repair-or-replace decision tool, document your tests, and fix list or sender-behavior problems before switching infrastructure. If replacement is commercially necessary, WarmInboxes offers options to evaluate, not a guarantee of inbox placement.
Questions people ask
Is a domain reputation checker accurate?
It can accurately report the public signals it tests. No third-party checker can reveal every private decision made by every mailbox provider.
Why does my domain pass all checks but emails still reach spam?
Authentication and DNS are prerequisites, not promises of placement. Complaint history, reputation, relevance, sender behavior, filtering and recipient-specific factors still matter.
Can I check a domain without sending an email?
You can inspect DNS and public RBLs without sending, but you cannot observe real message placement until a message is sent and its outcome is measured.
Next: Run an inbox placement test to add observed placement to your technical checks.
Sources
Related guides